A Review of “The Great Adventure at Washington” by Mark Sullivan
- Reviews of the Day from 1922 for “The Great Adventure at Washington”
- Selected Insights of Mark Sullivan from “The Great Adventure at Washington”
- This Author’s Review of “The Great Adventure at Washington” by Mark Sullivan
Reviews of the Day from 1922 for “The Great Adventure at Washington”
- A Review from Trenton Sunday Times-Advertiser, May 21, 1922
|
“In his conclusions Mr. Sullivan speaks exceedingly high praise of the things accomplished at the conference, as they appear in his eyes. There was achieved peacefully, as the writer interprets it, what ordinarily could not have been achieved without great bloodshed.
“The conference has done what nothing else could have done save a mighty and world-decisive naval battle. He remarks that the conference has destroyed more ships of war than any Admiral has done in history, regardless of the might of his fleet. It has changed sea rivals into sea partners. It has averted that peculiarly fatal competition for sea supremacy which, history tells us in no uncertain terms, always, because of itself, goes before war. "Mark Sullivan believes also that it has averted what otherwise would have been an inevitable struggle between Britain and the United States for sea rule. …… |
Mark Sullivan
|
“So much for Mr. Sullivan's conclusions as to the success of the conference. The methods of the conclave, its personalities, its surprises, the spirit under which it was conducted, the disagreements which might have, but did not, wreck it--all these he has presented with vividness and dramatic effect.
“He describes more than adequately the great moments of the conference.
“This is really a very valuable book, whatever your point of view..”
“He describes more than adequately the great moments of the conference.
“This is really a very valuable book, whatever your point of view..”
Books and Authors, Trenton Sunday Times, May 21, 1922
- A Review from The New York Herald, May 14, 1922
“This convention, Mark Sullivan indicates, is to be considered one of the highwater marks of history; accordingly he treats it as though he were recording a climactic scene in the old Roman Senate, and writes with a keen eye for dramatic values and with a shrewd sense of the epic importance of what he sees enacted.
“From beginning to end he describes the work of the conference vividly and convincingly, portraying the principal delegates graphically and weaving an interesting narrative from their activities. …
“Even though many of the aims of the conference were not achieved, Mark Sullivan writes that the seeds were sown for the convoking of other and even more successful conventions; a naval partnership of the most important powers on earth was consummated; a new precedent for international association was set, and the cornerstone was laid for what may ultimately prove the peaceful unification of the entire civilized world.”
“From beginning to end he describes the work of the conference vividly and convincingly, portraying the principal delegates graphically and weaving an interesting narrative from their activities. …
“Even though many of the aims of the conference were not achieved, Mark Sullivan writes that the seeds were sown for the convoking of other and even more successful conventions; a naval partnership of the most important powers on earth was consummated; a new precedent for international association was set, and the cornerstone was laid for what may ultimately prove the peaceful unification of the entire civilized world.”
Lights on the Washington Conference, The New York Herald, May 19, 1922
- A Review from The New York Times Book Review and Magazine, May 14, 1922
|
“Mark Sullivan of The Evening Post, an eye and ear witness of the late Conference for Limitation of Armament, has written an excellent book about it. …
“In the preface, rightly observing that histories written long after the event gain in fullness of material but lose in vividness, he frankly presents this book as a history which is intended to preserve the powerful impression of the moment. … The whole preface ought to be read not only as an instance of that obsolescent virtue of modesty, but also as the expression of some sound intellectual and ethical standards, valid both for historians in perspective and for the contemporary historian« who write for the newspapers. … |
From left to right: Mark Sullivan, H. G. Wells and William Allen White.
|
“Vividness Mr. Sullivan has certainly obtained, and a rapid running narrative that is not delayed even by the long footnotes or quotations from news dispatches.
“His book is full of sharply drawn pictures, physical or psychological.”
“His book is full of sharply drawn pictures, physical or psychological.”
At the Washington Conference, The New York Times, May 14, 1922
Selected Insights of Mark Sullivan from “The Great Adventure at Washington”
- The Preface: Insights into Capturing a Vivid or an Exhaustive Historical Event
As the last review above by The New York Times says, “the whole preface ought to be read.” Here is an excerpt that should interest a potential reader in this beginning chapter of “The Great Adventure at Washington.”
|
“You can't do anything that involves as much work and thought as this book did without learning a good deal.
"One of the most penetrating reflections that arose out of putting this book together is on the difference between writing history long after the event, and writing it while it is in the making. The latter process has handicaps, which are both great and obvious; but also it has advantages that are great but not obvious. “We commonly say that an adequate and comprehensive history of an event like the Washington Conference can only be written years later--after all the documents have become accessible. That is true. But it is also true that what these later and more pretentious histories may gain in exhaustiveness, they are pretty sure to lose in vividness. … |
Rear Admiral Sir David Beatty
|
“I know that all the official documents in the world can't convey as much essential fact to the distant and future reader as did the look on Lord Beatty’s face [First Sea Lord—the senior British naval expert and delegate at the conference] to the historian who had the advantage of being in the room when Mr. Hughes [U.S. Secretary of State who organized and chaired the peace conference], in that sensational opening speech of his, when he said that he would expect the British to scrap their four great HMS Hood Battlecruisers, and made equally irreverent mention of the King George the Fifth. …
“The point I am making is merely that the vividness of scenes like this is the advantage that the contemporary historian—even though a hurried journalist, with no pretense to exhaustiveness or authoritativeness, or even to absolute accuracy—has over the formal historian who must depend on documents."
“The point I am making is merely that the vividness of scenes like this is the advantage that the contemporary historian—even though a hurried journalist, with no pretense to exhaustiveness or authoritativeness, or even to absolute accuracy—has over the formal historian who must depend on documents."
The Preface, The Great Adventure at Washington, Mark Sullivan, 1922
- The Burial of the “Unknown Soldier” Set the Tone for Americans at the Conference
|
“I suspect that in Harding's mind, as in my own, and in the minds of nearly all the delegates and others in Washington at the time, the two events [burial of the ‘unknown soldier’ and the Washington Peace Conference] coming on two succeeding days were merged, in a sense, and were felt as one—the burial of the unknown soldier, who symbolized our grief over the sacrifices of the war just passed; and the opening of the Conference, which symbolized our hope of making other such sacrifices unnecessary.
“Certain it is that the most earnest and moving part of this speech of [President] Warren Harding's at the Conference opening was the passage in which he spoke the emotions that had come to him the day before. Harding spoke the following words in opening the conference: |
Woodrow Wilson attending dedication of the tomb of the unknown soldier.
|
“ ‘Here in the United States we are but freshly turned from the burial of an unknown American soldier, when a nation sorrowed while paying him tribute. Whether it was spoken or not, a hundred millions of our people were summarizing the inexcusable causes, the incalculable cost, the unspeakable sacrifices, and the unutterable sorrows; and there was the ever-impelling question: How can humanity justify or God forgive?
“ ‘Human hate demands no such toll; ambition and greed must be denied it.
“ ‘If misunderstanding must take the blame, then let us banish it. … I can speak officially only for the United States. Our hundred millions frankly want less of armament and none of war.’
“The approval of the audience at the conference for this sentiment was immediate and prolonged.”
Chapter 1, The Great Adventure at Washington, Mark Sullivan, 1922
Mark Sullivan Put a Face, an Attitude, and a Warm Rapport Around Those He Wrote About
- Mark Sullivan wrote the following of Prince Tokugawa, a Japanese delegate at the conference:
|
“Then, in the same way, the crowd called for Tokugawa.
“Tokugawa is a Prince and the eighteenth descendant in the line of the Shoguns; but he is also a most smiling, open-faced person whose beaming, humorous, good nature gives denial to the assumption that all Japanese are inscrutable. “Tokugawa looks and acts like a friendly, neighborly grocer in a smallish American town, a grocer who would find quite as much satisfaction in gossiping with his customers as in selling them sugar or collecting bills from them. “He spoke a few gracious words which, together with his manner, gave him a place in the kindly regard of the Conference that grew steadily till the day he left for Japan.” |
Prince Tokugawa
|
- Mark Sullivan wrote the following of Baron Kato Tomosaburo, Principal Japanese Spokesman
In 1922, shortly after the Washington Peace Conference, Baron Kato was appointed Prime Minister of Japan.
|
“Baron Kato had the appearance of wanness—paleness, and repression—a response of silence. ...
“In appearance, as well as intellectually, Baron Kato was one of the most impressive men in Washington. His eyes peered out from his well-proportioned head like the glowing focus of an immense and acute intelligence. "That was the appearance of Baron Kato at all times, and on this closing day he looked like a man who must sit still and listen to something far from agreeable. “He was listening to a judgment on certain actions of his country; and he knew those actions were disapproved by the world. Baron Kato personally may have felt one way or the other about those actions; but however he may have felt, he was hound to defend them, and had defended them and had fought steadily for his country’s position.”
|
Baron Kato
|
- Mark Sullivan wrote the following of Elihu Root, an American delegate at the conference:
|
Mr. Root in Washington was an impressive figure, and the sort of thing he now did was characteristic of the role he played throughout the conference. Elihu Root, as he appeared at the Washington Conference, was a spectacle to command attention like some splendid monument.
“There he stood, at the age of seventy-six, with a brain that was richly endowed in the beginning, and has now the acute refinement and fine efficiency that comes of a lifetime of hard intellectual work. It was easy to envisage him, at his age and with his philosophic temperament, surveying the world from the standpoint of one who must have begun to consider the time when he shall have left it. “Looking at the world with this serene abstraction, and determined to bequeath to it the heritage of the best work of a career already crowded with achievement, he considered the tides of evolution and the stars of direction and put his mind upon what was best to be done about that four hundred million human beings [in China] who compose the largest single nation on the earth's surface—what is best to be done. … |
Elihu Root
|
“Mr. Root engaged in this process was a spectacle to enrich the imagination. At an age and with a relation to the world that frees him from any necessity for considerations of party or factional or personal interest, he takes the visible universe for his client and lays down a course of action whose results will have a fairly large determining influence on what the world is to be a century after Mr. Root has departed from it.”
Chapter X: Japan and China, The Great Adventure at Washington, Mark Sullivan, 1922
This Author's Thoughts on Mark Sullivan’s "The Great Adventure at Washington"
In the last chapter of the book, “Unique in History,” Mark Sullivan discusses what made this term—Unique in History, a common phrase around the world for years to come. Lord Balfour, former Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, coined the phrase to describe the progress made towards peace at the Conference for Limitation of Armament held in Washington D. C. in 1921. [See Footnote Number #1 Below]
“At the conference, Great Britain surrendered actual dominance of naval power and we surrendered potential dominance. Great Britain gave up the heritage she had held for more than two hundred years; and we gave up the ambition to take it from her for ourselves. It was, as I have said, in a sense placed in a partnership to be administered for the common good.
“It was this peaceful passing of naval dominance, or, to express it more accurately, this turning over of dominance to, so to speak, a board of trustees, making it no longer a prize of selfishness to be contended for by jealous nations, but rather a cooperative responsibility to be administered jointly, that made the Washington Conference ‘unique in history.’ ”
It is too bad that the "board of trustees" would eventually lose its power and another World War would break out between the same players as in World War I. As Mr. Sullivan would say at the conference he was close to those who intended to do good, but history brought forth other players who were not so good and forthright in their handling of humanity and the relationship of countries in the world.
An amazing attempt to put humanity on the right path, but as Ida M. Tarbell summarized of this same conference:
“What the conference all amounted to was that the most drastic limitation on armament was no sure guarantee against future war. Take away a man's gun and it is no guarantee that he will still not strike if aroused. You must get at the man—enlarge his respect for order, his contempt for violence, change his notion of procedure in disputes, establish his control. It takes more than “gun toting” to make a dangerous citizen, more than relieving him of his gun to make a safe one. …
In this case, it appears that Miss Ida M. Tarbell saw more clearly into the future after the "American Conference for Limitation on Armament" than Mr. Sullivan.
Putting the two journalists’ perspectives together provides tremendous food for thought today!
Cheers,
Peter E. Greulich
“At the conference, Great Britain surrendered actual dominance of naval power and we surrendered potential dominance. Great Britain gave up the heritage she had held for more than two hundred years; and we gave up the ambition to take it from her for ourselves. It was, as I have said, in a sense placed in a partnership to be administered for the common good.
“It was this peaceful passing of naval dominance, or, to express it more accurately, this turning over of dominance to, so to speak, a board of trustees, making it no longer a prize of selfishness to be contended for by jealous nations, but rather a cooperative responsibility to be administered jointly, that made the Washington Conference ‘unique in history.’ ”
It is too bad that the "board of trustees" would eventually lose its power and another World War would break out between the same players as in World War I. As Mr. Sullivan would say at the conference he was close to those who intended to do good, but history brought forth other players who were not so good and forthright in their handling of humanity and the relationship of countries in the world.
An amazing attempt to put humanity on the right path, but as Ida M. Tarbell summarized of this same conference:
“What the conference all amounted to was that the most drastic limitation on armament was no sure guarantee against future war. Take away a man's gun and it is no guarantee that he will still not strike if aroused. You must get at the man—enlarge his respect for order, his contempt for violence, change his notion of procedure in disputes, establish his control. It takes more than “gun toting” to make a dangerous citizen, more than relieving him of his gun to make a safe one. …
In this case, it appears that Miss Ida M. Tarbell saw more clearly into the future after the "American Conference for Limitation on Armament" than Mr. Sullivan.
Putting the two journalists’ perspectives together provides tremendous food for thought today!
Cheers,
Peter E. Greulich
[Footnote #1] Mr. Sullivan wrote the following: “Mr. Balfour, by the way, with his knowledge of the rise and fall of nations, and of the position that Great Britain has long held in the world, is probably as well equipped as any other man to see and comprehend just what was the thing that made the Washington Conference ‘unique in history.’ ”