DISCERNING READERS
  • Home
  • About
  • Books / Bibliography
    • Keys to Success >
      • Preface
      • Introduction
      • Appendix
      • You: The First Key
    • THINK Again! Series >
      • Ideas and High Ideals >
        • Preface
        • Introduction
        • Prologue
        • Insights into Tom Watson >
          • Tom Watson's Character
          • A Wartime Humanitarian
          • Democracy's Man O' War
          • An Exemplary Man
          • On Youth & Education
        • A Successful Rebranding
      • The Rometty Edition >
        • Preface
        • Foreword
        • Introduction
        • Business Talk Interview
        • Book Trailers and Videos
      • The World's Greatest Salesman >
        • Preface
        • Introduction
        • Workplace Safety
        • Images and Quotes
        • Book Trailers / Videos
    • A View from Beneath >
      • Preface
      • Resource Actions >
        • Two R.A. Days Hit Home
        • R.A. Day Kills Productivity
      • Business Talk Interview
      • Book Trailers and Videos
    • Essays on Leadership >
      • Democracy in Business
      • We Are All Assistants >
        • Frank Venner: We Are All Assistants
      • We Forgive Thoughtful Mistakes
    • Bibliography Overview >
      • Authors and Writers >
        • Garland, Hamlin
        • Wise, John S. >
          • Slave Auction
          • Tribute to Robert E. Lee
          • On Lincoln's Assassination
      • Capitalists >
        • Baruch, Bernard M. >
          • My Own Story
          • The Public Years >
            • A Review
            • Second Thoughts
        • Davison, Henry P.
        • Schiff, Jacob H.
      • Educators >
        • Washington, Booker T >
          • Up From Slavery
          • My Life and Work
          • Character Building
          • My Larger Education
          • The Man Farthest Down >
            • Booker T. Washington and John Burns
          • Future of American Negro >
            • Future of the Negro
      • IBM >
        • IBM Books >
          • IBM Classics
          • IBM Executives' Books
          • IBM Employees' Books
          • IBM Outsiders' Books
        • IBM Publications >
          • THINK Magazine
          • Business Machines
          • IBM Heart and Soul >
            • Endicott Memorial Day
            • Poughkeepsie Memorial Day
          • IBM Art Books
        • IBM Situational
      • Industrialists >
        • Anthologies >
          • The Book of Business
          • New Ideals in Business
          • Master Workers' Library
          • The Age of Big Business
          • Famous Leaders Series Home Page >
            • Leaders of Character
            • Leaders of Industry: 1st Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 2nd Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 3rd Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 6th Series
          • Forbes' Anthologies
        • Armour, J. Ogden >
          • The Packers
          • The Packers: Second Look
        • Baldwin, William H.
        • Beatty, Edward
        • Bell, Alexander Graham
        • Carnegie, Andrew >
          • Carnegie Quotes
          • Carnegie Autobiography
          • Carnegie Biography by B. J. Hendrick
          • Round the World
          • The Empire of Business
          • An American Four-in-Hand
        • Eastman, George
        • Edison, Thomas A. >
          • Edison: His Life and Inventions
          • Edison: My Friend
        • Farquhar, A. B.
        • Filene, Edward A. >
          • The Way Out >
            • Captains of Industry vs. Captains of Finance
          • Successful Living >
            • Rules of Success
        • Firestone, Harvey S. >
          • Men and Rubber
          • Making an Organization
        • Flint, Charles R.
        • Ford, Henry >
          • Books by Henry Ford
          • The Last Billionaire
          • My Forty Years with Ford
        • Gary, Elbert H.
        • Guggenheim, William
        • Hill, James J.
        • Hollerith, Herman
        • Johnson, George F.
        • Patterson, John H.
        • Penney, James C. >
          • Fifty Years With the Golden Rule
        • Procter, William C.
        • Rockefeller Jr.
        • Rockefeller Sr.
        • Rosenwald, Julius
        • Sloan Jr., Alfred P.
        • Swope, Gerard >
          • Swope of G.E.
          • The Swope Plan
          • Selected Addresses
        • Verity, George M. >
          • True Steel
          • Character & Success
        • Wanamaker, John >
          • A Business Biography
          • Retail Firsts
        • Watson Jr., Thomas J. >
          • A Business and Its Beliefs
          • Management Briefings
          • Father, Son & Company
        • Watson Sr., Thomas J. >
          • Human Relations
          • Men-Minutes-Money
          • The Lengthening Shadow
        • Young, Owen D. >
          • Selected Addresses
          • New Industrial Leader
      • Inventors & Innovators >
        • Fulton, Robert
        • Goodyear, Charles
      • Journalists >
        • Baker, Ray Stannard >
          • Autobiography
          • The Color Line
          • Woodrow Wilson
        • Crowther, Samuel >
          • Articles >
            • Bantam Ball Bearing
          • Biographies
          • Industrialist Anthology
          • "Why Men Strike" Review
        • Gunther, John >
          • Eisenhower
        • Steffens, Lincoln
        • Sullivan, Mark >
          • Our Times
          • The Education of an American
        • Tarbell, Ida M. >
          • Overview
          • Lincoln Centennial
          • Lincoln Publications
          • Corporate Publications
          • Fiction Publications
          • Other Publications >
            • Mme. (Madame) Roland
          • Magazine Articles >
            • Disbanding the Confederate Army
            • Disbanding the Union Army
        • White, William Allen >
          • Woodrow Wilson, The Man
      • Military Leaders >
        • Lee, General Robert E.
      • Pioneers / Explorers >
        • Byrd, Richard E. >
          • Alone
          • Discovery
          • Little America
        • Columbus, Christopher
        • Lindbergh, Charles
      • Politicians >
        • Eisenhower, Dwight D.
        • Hoover, Herbert >
          • American Individualism Book >
            • American Individualism Article
          • Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson
          • Problems of Lasting Peace
        • Lincoln, Abraham >
          • Lincoln in the Telegraph Office
          • Abraham Lincoln Books By Ida M. Tarbell
        • Mesta, Perle
        • O'Connor, Basil and FDR >
          • Friends and Partners (Against Polio)
        • Roosevelt, Theodore >
          • Roosevelt: A Story of Friendship
        • Roper, Daniel C. >
          • Fifty Years of Public Life
        • Taft, William H.
        • Wilson, Woodrow >
          • The New Freedom
          • The Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson
          • Wilson's Last Words
          • Wilson's Tasks and Life
          • Wilson's Life and Letters >
            • Volume IV: President
            • Volume V: Neutrality
            • Volume VI: Facing War
      • Preachers >
        • Fosdick, Harry Emerson >
          • The Meaning of Prayer
          • The Meaning of Faith
          • The Meaning of Service
          • Power to See It Through
      • Publishers >
        • Forbes, B. C. >
          • Men Who Are Making America
          • Men Who Are Making the West
          • Automotive Giants of America
          • Little Bits about Big Men
          • America's 50 Foremost Business Leaders
          • America's Twelve Master Salesmen
          • Scrapbook of Thoughts on Business of Life
          • 101 Unusual Experiences
          • Keys to Success
          • Teamwork
        • Fortune Magazine >
          • USA: The Permanent Revolution
        • Shaw, A. W. >
          • Handling Men >
            • Why We Are Hiring Women
            • The Dream Behind the Business
          • The Companion Series
    • Research Sites
    • Acknowledgements
  • 21st Century IBM
    • Corporate Performance >
      • Comparing KPIs
      • Brand Performance >
        • Forbes' Best Employer
      • Patent Performance >
        • 2021 Patent Performance
        • 2020 Patent Performance
        • 2019 Patent Performance
        • 2018 Patent Performance
      • Revenue Performance
    • Corporate Practices >
      • Acquisitions >
        • Acquisition: Red Hat >
          • A $35 Billion Gamble
          • IBM + Red Hat 2019 Results
        • Acquisitions: Goodwill
        • Acquisitions: Since 2001
      • Centralization >
        • A Lost Federation
        • The Need to Decentralize
      • Divestitures >
        • Kyndryl Analysis
        • Kyndryl Top Questions
        • Martin Schroeter
      • Employees >
        • Resource Actions
        • Age Discrimination >
          • Cutting Old Heads
        • Employee Engagement
        • Aren't Buying Into IBM
        • Massive Work Slowdown
        • Failure of Work at Home
      • Financial Engineering >
        • Workforce Rebalancing
        • Aggressive Bookkeeping
      • Shareholders >
        • Share Buybacks
        • Shareholder Risk
        • Overall Performance >
          • Revenue & Profit
          • Revenue & Profit Growth
          • Revenue & Profit Productivity
          • IBM Market Value
          • Shareholder Returns & Risk
          • Employment Security
        • Employee Engagement
        • Warren Buffett's Mistake
        • Do Share Buybacks Work?
    • CEO Performance >
      • Arvind Krishna Overview >
        • First Year Performance >
          • Revenue & Profit
          • Revenue & Profit Growth
          • Revenue & Profit Productivity
          • IBM Market Value
          • Shareholder Returns & Risk
          • Share Buybacks
        • The First 100 Days
      • Ginni Rometty Overview >
        • Shareholder Value
        • Shareholder Risk
        • Share Buybacks
        • Dividend Strategy
        • Acquisition Strategy
        • Revenue & Profit Productivity
        • Revenue & Profit Growth
        • Revenue & Profit
  • 20th Century IBM
    • Corporate Performance >
      • IBM's Greatest CEO >
        • Shareholder Returns
        • Revenue Growth
        • Revenue Per Employee
        • Profit Growth
        • Profit Per Employee
        • Market Value
        • Goodwill
        • Economic Contractions
        • Economic Expansions
        • Stock Market Headwinds
        • CEO Historic Footnotes >
          • IBM's Founding Team
          • Financial Engineering
          • The Greatest Gamble
    • Corporate Practices >
      • IBM Anniversaries
      • IBM Benefits
      • IBM Creativity >
        • IBM Cartoons
        • IBM Song Books
        • IBM UK Dictionary
        • IBM Computing Dictionary
      • IBM Wild Ducks >
        • The Wild Goose
        • Royal Dissenters
        • Corporate Constitution
        • Respect for the Individual
        • Service to the Customer
        • Pursuit of Excellence
    • Corporate Products >
      • 1890: U.S. Census
      • Dayton Scales in 1920
      • 1940: The Electromatic
    • Thomas J. Watson Sr. >
      • Quotes By Watson
      • Quotes About Watson
      • Articles By Watson >
        • On World Peace
        • On the Cost of War
        • On Public Education
        • On Thomas Jefferson
        • On Thoughtful Mistakes
        • On Stakeholder Relations
      • Articles About Watson >
        • A Gift of Retirement
        • A Gift of Home Ownership >
          • Construction Timeline
        • The $1,000-A-Day Chief Executive Officer
        • Employees are Valued
        • Democracy's Man o' War
        • Human Relations in 1956
        • A CEO Who Earned His Pay
        • The Story of "THINK" >
          • Two Journalists "THINK"
          • A Buddy Davis Interview
        • Learning from Crises
        • Tom Watson's Wild Ducks
        • The Lengthening Shadow
      • Slice of Life Stories >
        • Dali, Salvador
        • Drucker, Peter F. >
          • Authority and Power
          • Short-Term Thinking
          • A Corporate Culture
          • Raising Business Issues
          • Focus on Principles
          • Character and Manners
          • Knowledge Workers
          • Recognizing Ability
          • Individual Respect
          • Employee Paternalism
        • Eastman, George
        • Penney, J. C. (James Cash) >
          • Watson Homestead
          • Golden Rule Businesses
        • A 1943 Tax Problem
        • Fighting Discrimination
        • A Pajama Party
      • Pre-World War II >
        • Women in the Workplace
        • A Lost Dream of Peace
        • USO Camp Show Founder
      • World War II Effort >
        • Selling War Bonds
        • Production Awards
        • Controlling Profits
        • Machine Records Units
        • Wartime Contributions
        • Widows & Orphans Fund
        • Declaring Human Rights
        • Supporting Home Morale
        • Employee Military Service
        • War's End & Reconversion
      • Post-World War II >
        • Endicott Memorial
        • Poughkeepsie Memorial
        • Rehiring WWII Veterans
  • Articles
    • Corporate Articles >
      • High-Performance Corporations
      • The Art of the Restart
      • Crises, Recoveries & Lessons Learned
      • Strategy Should Create Human Relationships
      • A Time-Tested Corporate Constitution
      • IBM, JC Penney and The Golden Rule
      • How IBM Created its 20th Century Brand
      • The Greatest Business Risk of the 20th Century
      • How to Grow a Business
      • The Importance of Sales Productivity
      • How Much Is a Great CEO Worth
      • Let Your Guard Down
    • Business Articles >
      • Business Witticism
      • The Golden Rule and Productivity in Business
      • Who and What Built Early American Capitalism
      • Capitalism Needs Industrialist Minded CEOs
      • Producing Corporate True Steel
      • CEO Perspectives >
        • Rules of Success
        • Top Employee Qualities
        • Industrialist vs. Capitalist
      • An Open Letter to the World's CEOs
      • Henry Ford Takes Control
      • The Razor Blade Business Model
      • Two Successful 20th Century Businesswomen
      • Sears: A Dead Franchise Walking
      • A LinkedIn Incognito Mode
      • Value a College Education
    • Political Articles >
      • Political Witticisms
      • Meritocracy and Teachable Humility
      • What Is Patriotism?
      • Presidents' Day 2024-25
      • Memorial Day 2025
      • Pursuing The "American Way"
      • America: Home of the Brave
      • Securing the Borders of the Americas
      • General Grant's Stand for Justice
      • America's Heartland Stands Strong
      • The New Freedom
      • Teddy Roosevelt on Socialism & Individualism
      • Women as Citizens
      • Mary Slessor of Calabar
    • Spiritual Articles >
      • Inauguration Day Prayer
      • Reincarnated Thoughts >
        • Why Lies Should Never Be Glorified
        • Are You More Than A Wise Entrepreneur?
        • A World of Peace or Turbulence?
      • Wilson's Last Words
      • Spiritual Songs
    • Fiction Articles >
      • A Father's Love
      • Introducing a Friend to God
      • Hyphenated Relationships
  • Contact
  • Blog
Shareholder Returns by IBM CEO

Comparing IBM CEO Shareholder Returns

Date Published: August 5, 2021
Date Modified: June 29, 2024
A slide with the heading
 Overview of these Chief Executive Officer Performance Pages
Today, there is a raging debate among corporate stakeholders as to the wisdom of Wall Street's shareholder maximization fanaticism. This is what I call in my latest book: shareholder-first and -foremost, or me-first and -only. Tom Watson Sr. fought both of these philosophies in his time as chief executive. In fact he worked to ensure that all his stakeholders—his customers, employees, shareholders and societies—​were members of a supportive stakeholder ecosystem. The returns of IBM's shareholders were the greatest when this ecosystem was functioning properly. That will be evident in these charts.
A two-way sign: shareholder-first and -foremost or sustainable stakeholder ecosystem.
Tom Watson Sr. believed in "Two-Way Streets."
Let's start this evaluation of IBM's Chief Executive Officers with their historical shareholder returns. ​These charts assume the purchase of $1,000 of IBM stock on the first of the year each CEO assumed control and ending with their last full year in the corner office.
​
One major obstacle was to find a reliable, consistent, one-hundred-year benchmark to compare the shareholder returns of IBM's Chief Executive Officers. We are using Morningstar's® IA SBBI US Large Stock: Total Returns (previously Ibbotson's® Stocks, Bonds, Bills, and Inflation® (SBBI) Classic Yearbook). This information is available through Morningstar's Advisor Workstation. There may be more representative, individual benchmarks at times—such as technology stocks during Louis V. Gerstner's tenure; but the decision was made in this evaluation to prioritize historical comparative consistency over the anomalies of one particular period. Significant economic and political considerations are highlighted beneath each chart as facts worth noting.
But shareholder returns shouldn't be the only measurement. How do you decide if a CEO just happened to be at "the right place at the right time," or did they transcended the economic, political and competitive pressures of their decade(s) to achieve long-term success?
​Louis V. Gerstner's self-evaluation Who Says Elephants Can't Dance? fails to raise or answer any of these longer-term questions about his time as chief executive (which, of course, wasn't the purpose of his book):
  • How many economic recessions did they face? What was the length and depth of these recessions - depressions?
  • How many economic expansions did they face? How long and strong were these expansions?
  • What were the economic, political and competitive pressures during their time in charge?
  • What major actions did they take during their tenure? Did these actions set their predecessor up for success or failure?
  • Did these chief executives play it safe or take calculated risks to move the corporation forward?​​
  • ​Were their successes short- or long-term oriented? Were their failures learning experiences for the next chief executive?
  • Did they act decisively and in a timely fashion to implement necessary changes within the corporation? What were the short- and long-term effects of these decisions?
  • Did their actions energize and embolden the individual within corporation to think and act?
It takes a holistic perspective and this is just a starting point. More information follows to provide a more complete picture of each CEO's tenure. These pages will be updated as our studies continue and more current information becomes available.

Enjoy the journey. Let's start with shareholder returns.

Cheers

​- Peter E.
 IBM Chief Executive Officers' Shareholder Returns
 Summary of CEO Shareholder Returns
  • 30.03% CAGR in IBM Stock over 9 years: Louis V. (Lou) Gerstner 
  • 20.96% CAGR in IBM Stock over 15 years: Thomas J. Watson Jr. 
  • 16.69% CAGR in IBM Stock over 32 years: Thomas J. Watson Sr. ​
  • 16.05% CAGR in IBM Stock over 4 years: John R. Opel 
  • 12.47% CAGR in IBM Stock over 2 years: T. Vincent (Vin) Learson​
  •   5.66% CAGR in IBM Stock over 10 years: Samuel J. (Sam) Palmisano
  •     -.72% CAGR in IBM Stock over 8 years: Virginia M. (Ginni) Rometty
  •  -1.23% CAGR in IBM Stock over 1 year: Arvind Krishna
  •  -2.10% CAGR in IBM Stock over 8 years: Frank T. Cary 
  •  -7.26% CAGR in IBM Stock over 8 years: John F. Akers​
 At a Glance: Examining the Last Two Decades of Shareholder Returns: 1999 – 2020
  • Investment in IBM Stock: 3.59% CAGR
  • Investment in Large Company Stocks: 7.23% CAGR
  • Investment in Dow Jones Industrial Average: 8.13% CAGR
A color line graph showing IBM Stock Total Return on Investment from 1999 to 2020 compared with the Dow Jones Industrial Index (DJIA) and a large company stock index.
 -     Thomas J. (Tom) Watson Sr.: May 1914 – May 1956
  • Investment in IBM Stock: 16.69% CAGR
  • Investment in Large Company Stocks: 10.66% CAGR
A color line graph showing IBM Stock Total Return on Investment for Thomas J. Watson Sr. from 1923 to 1956 compared with a large company stock index.
Facts worth noting: The above returns are from 1923 through 1956—over three decades. The IBM Corporation documented, at the time of Watson Sr.'s death, that a purchase of 100 shares in 1914 (when Watson Sr. assumed control of IBM as the C-T-R Company) would have cost less than $3,000. By the time of his death, this would have become 4,987 shares with a market value of $2,274,072 (at $456 per share). This presumably (the article did not state this specific detail) included reinvestment of dividends. This is a CAGR of 17.10% over his full forty-two years leading IBM. Watson Sr. faced five recessions, the Great Depression and then four more recessions; he faced four of the six top U.S. stock market declines; and he also navigated the corporation through World Wars I, II and the Korean War.
 -     Thomas J. (Tom) Watson Jr.: Jun 1956 – May 1971
  • Investment in IBM Stock: 20.96% CAGR
  • Investment in Large Company Stocks: 8.78% CAGR
A color line graph showing IBM Stock Total Return on Investment for Thomas J. Watson Jr. from 1955 to 1972 compared with a large company stock index.
Facts worth noting: Watson Jr. completely changed the organizational structure and accountability model of IBM in 1956 when he took charge. He decentralized IBM and instituted a cultural identity throughout the corporation with three words: Respect, Service and Excellence. This change enabled him to accomplish the following: Internationally, at the beginning of 1956, corporate employment stood at 56,000, revenue at $700 million, and net income at $73 million. Rather than taking another four decades to match those numbers, Watson Jr. added, on average, 56,000 employees every four years, $700 million in revenue every year and a half, and $73 million in net income almost every year. By 1971, revenue per employee had grown by 150%, net income per employee by more than 200%, and the number of stockholders by more than 2,000%.
 -     T. Vincent (Vin) Learson: Jun 1971 – Dec 1972
  • Investment in IBM Stock: 12.47% CAGR
  • Investment in Large Company Stocks: 16.62% CAGR
A color line graph showing IBM Stock Total Return on Investment for T. Vincent (Vin) Learson from 1970 to 1972 compared with a large company stock index.
Facts worth noting: T. Vincent Learson should be considered Thomas J. Watson Jr.'s second in command and acerbic touchstone for the entire time he was Chief Executive at IBM - including the development of the mainframe. So, although this chart above shows the returns during his 18 months as chief executive, it is a microscopic part of the overall impact he had on overall shareholder returns.
 -     Frank T. Cary: Jan 1973 – Dec 1980
  • Investment in IBM Stock:  - 2.10% CAGR
  • Investment in Large Company Stocks: 6.53% CAGR
A color line graph showing IBM Stock Total Return on Investment for Frank T. Cary from 1971 to 1980 compared with a large company stock index.
​Facts worth noting: Frank Cary faced the most tumultuous of decades in IBM's history. This decade was earmarked by three Category Five storms in the economic, political and competitive arenas. It started with a massive investment failure in the Future Systems project. Mr Cary, with John R. Opel at his side, lost focus on managing the company by attempting to manage the stock: a 5-for-4 stock split, a first-time stock buyback program, and then a 4-for-1 stock split to supposedly increase the appeal of the stock to small investors. This was balanced, though, with a significant investment in corporate assets to take on the "Japanese threat" of the '70s. A great showing by a great chief executive only marred by stock-price experimentation that ultimately proved unsuccessful and should have served as a warning for the current 21st Century CEOs.
 -     John R. Opel: Jan 1981 – Jan 1985
  • Investment in IBM Stock:  16.05% CAGR
  • Investment in Large Company Stocks: 10.76% CAGR
A color line graph showing IBM Stock Total Return on Investment for John R. Opel from 1980 to 1984 compared with a large company stock index.
Facts worth noting: John R. Opel is the chief executive that set John F. Akers up for failure. One should not feel too much sympathy for John Akers, though, because he: (1) failed to react timely to change the corporation's direction after assuming control and (2) was on the board of directors when Mr. Opel sold off IBM's complete install base of lease/rental machines that put IBM on a "purchase only" footing. John Opel should be remember for replacing an annual, $1 gold piece with a one-time, devalued $2 paper note. This was a fire sale, pulling in revenue and profits from out years. It was financial engineering—following a short-term, financially expedient path at the expense of the long-term health of the business.
 -     John F. Akers: Feb 1985 – Mar 1993
  • Investment in IBM Stock:  - 7.26% CAGR
  • Investment in Large Company Stocks: 16.69% CAGR
A color line graph showing IBM Stock Total Return on Investment for John F. Akers from 1983 to 1992 compared with a large company stock index.
Facts worth noting: John F. Akers is the man remembered for the fall of IBM in the '90s. His predecessor, though, set up this fall by setting unreasonable market expectations and spending money as if they could be met. He talked of the $100 billion IBM by 1990 and $180 billion IBM by 1994. These were expectations founded on financial engineering that took place in the previous four years. With less than six months in the corner office, John Akers had to tell analysts that these expectations could not be realized. When he did, "two wire-service reporters quietly slipped out of the room, breaking into a run once they were out of earshot. A half-hour later … IBM’s stock had started to plummet. By day’s end it was down five points, taking the entire stock market with it … the next day the market dropped another 16 points.” It would have taken a chief executive of the caliber of one of the Watsons or a Frank Cary to have overcome such a start as chief executive.
 -     Louis V. (Lou) Gerstner: Apr 1993 – Feb 2002
  • Investment in IBM Stock:  30.03% CAGR
  • Investment in Large Company Stocks: 13.54% CAGR
A color line graph showing IBM Stock Total Return on Investment for Louis V. (Lou) Gerstner from 1993 to 2001 compared with a large company stock index.
Facts worth noting: Although the CAGR of IBM stock at 30.03% looks fabulous compared to the 13.54% return of our benchmark, one-hundred-year, consistent, cross-industry Morningstar IA SBBI US Large Company Stocks, it should be noted that the Dow Jones U. S. Technology Index (DJUSTC) from 1992 to 1999 yielded $12,503 to IBM's $9,387. Over the first seven years of this chart, this is a CAGR of 43.46% for technology stocks compared to IBM's 37.70%. Should IBM be considered a large company stock or a technology stock during this technology bubble from 1992 through 1999?

At a minimum, historians should be aware that IBM outperformed large company stocks but under performed within its peer group of technology stocks. ​Louis V. Gerstner states his case to be the greatest of IBM chief executives in Who Says Elephants Can't Dance?. This self-evaluation though leaves out too much to be considered an unbiased and complete evaluation of Mr. Gerstner's tenure in the corner office. He fails to: (1) document how the longest and strongest expansion in the history of the United States served as an economic tailwind for his nine years, (2) give credit to an old culture that wasn't dead but hibernating and re-emerged in 1993 to pull the company from the abyss of economic destruction, (3) fully understand how his pension actions in 1995 and 1999 destroyed a culture he never used to his long-term advantage as employee revenue and net income productivity start an eighteen year decline in 1999, (4) stop the quarterly resource actions he called "Chinese water torture" in 1993 as he told the press he would, and (5) finally, just a year after an $8 billion loss in 1993, he initiates stock buybacks that are the logical genesis for the earnings-per-share roadmaps of his successors (Palmisano and Rometty) in the following decade.
 -     Samuel J. (Sam) Palmisano: Mar 2002 – Dec 2011
  • Investment in IBM Stock:  5.66% CAGR
  • Investment in Large Company Stocks: 2.92% CAGR
A color line graph showing IBM Stock Total Return on Investment for Samuel J. (Sam) Palmisano from 2002 to 2011 compared with a large company stock index.
Facts worth noting: Samuel J. Palmisano invested on average $10 billion a year in stock repurchases over his tenure as Chief Executive. Yet an investor for nine of his ten years would have made more money or achieved an equivalent return with less risk in a large company stock index fund. He followed in the steps of his predecessor: a chief executive who failed to manage by wandering around (MBWA). As I traveled the world, I would ask salesmen what they though of Sam Palmisano. Usually the reply, made in a satirical tone of voice, was something of the nature, "Sam who?" This was a man that the press called one of IBM's most capable salesmen, yet if they had dug just a little deeper they would have known that, by now, all IBM salesmen had lost respect for their corner office as their Salesman-in-Chief. The defining moment of his tenure as chief executive: an undying commitment to two earnings-per-share roadmaps rather than making business investments. Employees commented internally, "We are just roadkill on the roadside of these roadmaps."
 -     Virginia M. (Ginni) Rometty: Jan 2012 – Mar 2020
  • Investment in IBM Stock:  -.72% CAGR
  • Investment in Large Company Stocks: 14.89% CAGR
  • Investment in Dow Jones Industrial Average: 13.97% CAGR
A color line graph showing IBM Stock Total Return on Investment for Virginia M. (Ginni) Rometty from 2012 to 2019 compared with a large company stock index.
​Facts worth noting: Virginia M. Rometty policies were the policies of her predecessors: (1) on-going, quarterly resource actions to increase earnings, (2) failure to understand the required connection between sales' requirements and product development to produce products of higher value for her customers, (3) managing the stock price rather than the business by investing critical profit dollars in paper rather than technology--on average, $7.2 billion a year in stock buybacks from 2012 to 2019. Detailed performance information for Virginia M. (Ginni) Rometty is: [here].
 -     Arvind Krishna: Apr 2020 – Present
  • Investment in IBM Stock: -1.23% CAGR
  • Investment in Large Company Stocks: 18.40% CAGR
  • Investment in Dow Jones Industrial Average: 9.72% CAGR
A color line graph showing IBM Stock Total Return on Investment for Arvind Krishna for 2020 compared with a large company stock index.
Facts worth noting: Virginia M. Rometty "suspended" share buybacks with the acquisition of Red Hat in 2019. There is still $2 billion authorized by the board of directors that is unspent. The Red Hat acquisition was a $35.1 billion acquisition—​approximately $3 million per employee. James (Jim) Whitehurst has exited the company. Arvind Krishna detailed performance information is: [here].

Return to "Who Was ibm's greatest ceo?" Home Page
© 2025 Peter E. Greulich. All Rights Reserved
Information posted on this site recognizes the legal right of copyrighted material. The following material is considered in the public domain effective January 1, 2025: (1) Works published in the United States prior to 1930, (2) All unpublished works created over 120 years ago, (3) Works published in the United States before 1978 that have no © copyright notice, and (4) Works published in the United States after 1929 but before 1964 with a proper © copyright notice that were not renewed in their 28th year. Some information is used here that does not fit this criteria. This type of material has been purposely minimized, and it is used in good faith, usually with an attribution, and in the belief that such usage would withstand a test of fair use. This site also utilizes images from Pixabay that are "free to use under the Pixabay license" and "do not require attribution." Any concerns with the public domain, fair usage, or attribution of material utilized on this site will be removed until a discussion can resolve the matter with its permanent removal or republication. To reach us, use the "Contact" menu item above or this hyperlink: [Contact Us]
  • Home
  • About
  • Books / Bibliography
    • Keys to Success >
      • Preface
      • Introduction
      • Appendix
      • You: The First Key
    • THINK Again! Series >
      • Ideas and High Ideals >
        • Preface
        • Introduction
        • Prologue
        • Insights into Tom Watson >
          • Tom Watson's Character
          • A Wartime Humanitarian
          • Democracy's Man O' War
          • An Exemplary Man
          • On Youth & Education
        • A Successful Rebranding
      • The Rometty Edition >
        • Preface
        • Foreword
        • Introduction
        • Business Talk Interview
        • Book Trailers and Videos
      • The World's Greatest Salesman >
        • Preface
        • Introduction
        • Workplace Safety
        • Images and Quotes
        • Book Trailers / Videos
    • A View from Beneath >
      • Preface
      • Resource Actions >
        • Two R.A. Days Hit Home
        • R.A. Day Kills Productivity
      • Business Talk Interview
      • Book Trailers and Videos
    • Essays on Leadership >
      • Democracy in Business
      • We Are All Assistants >
        • Frank Venner: We Are All Assistants
      • We Forgive Thoughtful Mistakes
    • Bibliography Overview >
      • Authors and Writers >
        • Garland, Hamlin
        • Wise, John S. >
          • Slave Auction
          • Tribute to Robert E. Lee
          • On Lincoln's Assassination
      • Capitalists >
        • Baruch, Bernard M. >
          • My Own Story
          • The Public Years >
            • A Review
            • Second Thoughts
        • Davison, Henry P.
        • Schiff, Jacob H.
      • Educators >
        • Washington, Booker T >
          • Up From Slavery
          • My Life and Work
          • Character Building
          • My Larger Education
          • The Man Farthest Down >
            • Booker T. Washington and John Burns
          • Future of American Negro >
            • Future of the Negro
      • IBM >
        • IBM Books >
          • IBM Classics
          • IBM Executives' Books
          • IBM Employees' Books
          • IBM Outsiders' Books
        • IBM Publications >
          • THINK Magazine
          • Business Machines
          • IBM Heart and Soul >
            • Endicott Memorial Day
            • Poughkeepsie Memorial Day
          • IBM Art Books
        • IBM Situational
      • Industrialists >
        • Anthologies >
          • The Book of Business
          • New Ideals in Business
          • Master Workers' Library
          • The Age of Big Business
          • Famous Leaders Series Home Page >
            • Leaders of Character
            • Leaders of Industry: 1st Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 2nd Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 3rd Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 6th Series
          • Forbes' Anthologies
        • Armour, J. Ogden >
          • The Packers
          • The Packers: Second Look
        • Baldwin, William H.
        • Beatty, Edward
        • Bell, Alexander Graham
        • Carnegie, Andrew >
          • Carnegie Quotes
          • Carnegie Autobiography
          • Carnegie Biography by B. J. Hendrick
          • Round the World
          • The Empire of Business
          • An American Four-in-Hand
        • Eastman, George
        • Edison, Thomas A. >
          • Edison: His Life and Inventions
          • Edison: My Friend
        • Farquhar, A. B.
        • Filene, Edward A. >
          • The Way Out >
            • Captains of Industry vs. Captains of Finance
          • Successful Living >
            • Rules of Success
        • Firestone, Harvey S. >
          • Men and Rubber
          • Making an Organization
        • Flint, Charles R.
        • Ford, Henry >
          • Books by Henry Ford
          • The Last Billionaire
          • My Forty Years with Ford
        • Gary, Elbert H.
        • Guggenheim, William
        • Hill, James J.
        • Hollerith, Herman
        • Johnson, George F.
        • Patterson, John H.
        • Penney, James C. >
          • Fifty Years With the Golden Rule
        • Procter, William C.
        • Rockefeller Jr.
        • Rockefeller Sr.
        • Rosenwald, Julius
        • Sloan Jr., Alfred P.
        • Swope, Gerard >
          • Swope of G.E.
          • The Swope Plan
          • Selected Addresses
        • Verity, George M. >
          • True Steel
          • Character & Success
        • Wanamaker, John >
          • A Business Biography
          • Retail Firsts
        • Watson Jr., Thomas J. >
          • A Business and Its Beliefs
          • Management Briefings
          • Father, Son & Company
        • Watson Sr., Thomas J. >
          • Human Relations
          • Men-Minutes-Money
          • The Lengthening Shadow
        • Young, Owen D. >
          • Selected Addresses
          • New Industrial Leader
      • Inventors & Innovators >
        • Fulton, Robert
        • Goodyear, Charles
      • Journalists >
        • Baker, Ray Stannard >
          • Autobiography
          • The Color Line
          • Woodrow Wilson
        • Crowther, Samuel >
          • Articles >
            • Bantam Ball Bearing
          • Biographies
          • Industrialist Anthology
          • "Why Men Strike" Review
        • Gunther, John >
          • Eisenhower
        • Steffens, Lincoln
        • Sullivan, Mark >
          • Our Times
          • The Education of an American
        • Tarbell, Ida M. >
          • Overview
          • Lincoln Centennial
          • Lincoln Publications
          • Corporate Publications
          • Fiction Publications
          • Other Publications >
            • Mme. (Madame) Roland
          • Magazine Articles >
            • Disbanding the Confederate Army
            • Disbanding the Union Army
        • White, William Allen >
          • Woodrow Wilson, The Man
      • Military Leaders >
        • Lee, General Robert E.
      • Pioneers / Explorers >
        • Byrd, Richard E. >
          • Alone
          • Discovery
          • Little America
        • Columbus, Christopher
        • Lindbergh, Charles
      • Politicians >
        • Eisenhower, Dwight D.
        • Hoover, Herbert >
          • American Individualism Book >
            • American Individualism Article
          • Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson
          • Problems of Lasting Peace
        • Lincoln, Abraham >
          • Lincoln in the Telegraph Office
          • Abraham Lincoln Books By Ida M. Tarbell
        • Mesta, Perle
        • O'Connor, Basil and FDR >
          • Friends and Partners (Against Polio)
        • Roosevelt, Theodore >
          • Roosevelt: A Story of Friendship
        • Roper, Daniel C. >
          • Fifty Years of Public Life
        • Taft, William H.
        • Wilson, Woodrow >
          • The New Freedom
          • The Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson
          • Wilson's Last Words
          • Wilson's Tasks and Life
          • Wilson's Life and Letters >
            • Volume IV: President
            • Volume V: Neutrality
            • Volume VI: Facing War
      • Preachers >
        • Fosdick, Harry Emerson >
          • The Meaning of Prayer
          • The Meaning of Faith
          • The Meaning of Service
          • Power to See It Through
      • Publishers >
        • Forbes, B. C. >
          • Men Who Are Making America
          • Men Who Are Making the West
          • Automotive Giants of America
          • Little Bits about Big Men
          • America's 50 Foremost Business Leaders
          • America's Twelve Master Salesmen
          • Scrapbook of Thoughts on Business of Life
          • 101 Unusual Experiences
          • Keys to Success
          • Teamwork
        • Fortune Magazine >
          • USA: The Permanent Revolution
        • Shaw, A. W. >
          • Handling Men >
            • Why We Are Hiring Women
            • The Dream Behind the Business
          • The Companion Series
    • Research Sites
    • Acknowledgements
  • 21st Century IBM
    • Corporate Performance >
      • Comparing KPIs
      • Brand Performance >
        • Forbes' Best Employer
      • Patent Performance >
        • 2021 Patent Performance
        • 2020 Patent Performance
        • 2019 Patent Performance
        • 2018 Patent Performance
      • Revenue Performance
    • Corporate Practices >
      • Acquisitions >
        • Acquisition: Red Hat >
          • A $35 Billion Gamble
          • IBM + Red Hat 2019 Results
        • Acquisitions: Goodwill
        • Acquisitions: Since 2001
      • Centralization >
        • A Lost Federation
        • The Need to Decentralize
      • Divestitures >
        • Kyndryl Analysis
        • Kyndryl Top Questions
        • Martin Schroeter
      • Employees >
        • Resource Actions
        • Age Discrimination >
          • Cutting Old Heads
        • Employee Engagement
        • Aren't Buying Into IBM
        • Massive Work Slowdown
        • Failure of Work at Home
      • Financial Engineering >
        • Workforce Rebalancing
        • Aggressive Bookkeeping
      • Shareholders >
        • Share Buybacks
        • Shareholder Risk
        • Overall Performance >
          • Revenue & Profit
          • Revenue & Profit Growth
          • Revenue & Profit Productivity
          • IBM Market Value
          • Shareholder Returns & Risk
          • Employment Security
        • Employee Engagement
        • Warren Buffett's Mistake
        • Do Share Buybacks Work?
    • CEO Performance >
      • Arvind Krishna Overview >
        • First Year Performance >
          • Revenue & Profit
          • Revenue & Profit Growth
          • Revenue & Profit Productivity
          • IBM Market Value
          • Shareholder Returns & Risk
          • Share Buybacks
        • The First 100 Days
      • Ginni Rometty Overview >
        • Shareholder Value
        • Shareholder Risk
        • Share Buybacks
        • Dividend Strategy
        • Acquisition Strategy
        • Revenue & Profit Productivity
        • Revenue & Profit Growth
        • Revenue & Profit
  • 20th Century IBM
    • Corporate Performance >
      • IBM's Greatest CEO >
        • Shareholder Returns
        • Revenue Growth
        • Revenue Per Employee
        • Profit Growth
        • Profit Per Employee
        • Market Value
        • Goodwill
        • Economic Contractions
        • Economic Expansions
        • Stock Market Headwinds
        • CEO Historic Footnotes >
          • IBM's Founding Team
          • Financial Engineering
          • The Greatest Gamble
    • Corporate Practices >
      • IBM Anniversaries
      • IBM Benefits
      • IBM Creativity >
        • IBM Cartoons
        • IBM Song Books
        • IBM UK Dictionary
        • IBM Computing Dictionary
      • IBM Wild Ducks >
        • The Wild Goose
        • Royal Dissenters
        • Corporate Constitution
        • Respect for the Individual
        • Service to the Customer
        • Pursuit of Excellence
    • Corporate Products >
      • 1890: U.S. Census
      • Dayton Scales in 1920
      • 1940: The Electromatic
    • Thomas J. Watson Sr. >
      • Quotes By Watson
      • Quotes About Watson
      • Articles By Watson >
        • On World Peace
        • On the Cost of War
        • On Public Education
        • On Thomas Jefferson
        • On Thoughtful Mistakes
        • On Stakeholder Relations
      • Articles About Watson >
        • A Gift of Retirement
        • A Gift of Home Ownership >
          • Construction Timeline
        • The $1,000-A-Day Chief Executive Officer
        • Employees are Valued
        • Democracy's Man o' War
        • Human Relations in 1956
        • A CEO Who Earned His Pay
        • The Story of "THINK" >
          • Two Journalists "THINK"
          • A Buddy Davis Interview
        • Learning from Crises
        • Tom Watson's Wild Ducks
        • The Lengthening Shadow
      • Slice of Life Stories >
        • Dali, Salvador
        • Drucker, Peter F. >
          • Authority and Power
          • Short-Term Thinking
          • A Corporate Culture
          • Raising Business Issues
          • Focus on Principles
          • Character and Manners
          • Knowledge Workers
          • Recognizing Ability
          • Individual Respect
          • Employee Paternalism
        • Eastman, George
        • Penney, J. C. (James Cash) >
          • Watson Homestead
          • Golden Rule Businesses
        • A 1943 Tax Problem
        • Fighting Discrimination
        • A Pajama Party
      • Pre-World War II >
        • Women in the Workplace
        • A Lost Dream of Peace
        • USO Camp Show Founder
      • World War II Effort >
        • Selling War Bonds
        • Production Awards
        • Controlling Profits
        • Machine Records Units
        • Wartime Contributions
        • Widows & Orphans Fund
        • Declaring Human Rights
        • Supporting Home Morale
        • Employee Military Service
        • War's End & Reconversion
      • Post-World War II >
        • Endicott Memorial
        • Poughkeepsie Memorial
        • Rehiring WWII Veterans
  • Articles
    • Corporate Articles >
      • High-Performance Corporations
      • The Art of the Restart
      • Crises, Recoveries & Lessons Learned
      • Strategy Should Create Human Relationships
      • A Time-Tested Corporate Constitution
      • IBM, JC Penney and The Golden Rule
      • How IBM Created its 20th Century Brand
      • The Greatest Business Risk of the 20th Century
      • How to Grow a Business
      • The Importance of Sales Productivity
      • How Much Is a Great CEO Worth
      • Let Your Guard Down
    • Business Articles >
      • Business Witticism
      • The Golden Rule and Productivity in Business
      • Who and What Built Early American Capitalism
      • Capitalism Needs Industrialist Minded CEOs
      • Producing Corporate True Steel
      • CEO Perspectives >
        • Rules of Success
        • Top Employee Qualities
        • Industrialist vs. Capitalist
      • An Open Letter to the World's CEOs
      • Henry Ford Takes Control
      • The Razor Blade Business Model
      • Two Successful 20th Century Businesswomen
      • Sears: A Dead Franchise Walking
      • A LinkedIn Incognito Mode
      • Value a College Education
    • Political Articles >
      • Political Witticisms
      • Meritocracy and Teachable Humility
      • What Is Patriotism?
      • Presidents' Day 2024-25
      • Memorial Day 2025
      • Pursuing The "American Way"
      • America: Home of the Brave
      • Securing the Borders of the Americas
      • General Grant's Stand for Justice
      • America's Heartland Stands Strong
      • The New Freedom
      • Teddy Roosevelt on Socialism & Individualism
      • Women as Citizens
      • Mary Slessor of Calabar
    • Spiritual Articles >
      • Inauguration Day Prayer
      • Reincarnated Thoughts >
        • Why Lies Should Never Be Glorified
        • Are You More Than A Wise Entrepreneur?
        • A World of Peace or Turbulence?
      • Wilson's Last Words
      • Spiritual Songs
    • Fiction Articles >
      • A Father's Love
      • Introducing a Friend to God
      • Hyphenated Relationships
  • Contact
  • Blog