DISCERNING READERS
  • Home
  • About
  • Books / Bibliography
    • THINK Again! >
      • Preface
      • Foreword
      • Introduction
      • Business Talk Interview
      • Book Trailers and Videos
    • A View from Beneath >
      • Preface
      • Resource Actions >
        • Two R.A. Days Hit Home
        • R.A. Day Kills Productivity
      • Business Talk Interview
      • Book Trailers and Videos
    • The World's Greatest Salesman >
      • Preface
      • Introduction
      • Workplace Safety
      • Images and Quotes
      • Book Trailers / Videos
    • Essays on Leadership >
      • Democracy in Business
      • We Are All Assistants >
        • Frank Venner: We Are All Assistants
      • We Forgive Thoughtful Mistakes
    • Bibliography Overview >
      • IBM >
        • IBM Books >
          • IBM Classics
          • IBM Executives' Books
          • IBM Employees' Books
          • IBM Outsiders' Books
        • IBM Publications >
          • THINK Magazine
          • Business Machines
          • IBM Heart and Soul >
            • Endicott Memorial Day
            • Poughkeepsie Memorial Day
          • IBM Art Books
        • IBM Situational
      • Industrialists >
        • Anthologies >
          • The Book of Business
          • New Ideals in Business
          • Master Workers' Library
          • The Age of Big Business
          • Famous Leaders Series Home Page >
            • Leaders of Character
            • Leaders of Industry: 1st Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 2nd Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 3rd Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 6th Series
          • Forbes' Anthologies
        • Armour, J. Ogden >
          • The Packers
          • The Packers: Second Look
        • Baldwin, William H.
        • Beatty, Edward
        • Bell, Alexander Graham
        • Carnegie, Andrew >
          • Carnegie Quotes
          • Carnegie Autobiography
          • Carnegie Biography by B. J. Hendrick
          • Round the World
          • The Empire of Business
          • An American Four-in-Hand
        • Eastman, George
        • Edison, Thomas A. >
          • Edison: His Life and Inventions
          • Edison: My Friend
        • Farquhar, A. B.
        • Filene, Edward A. >
          • The Way Out >
            • Captains of Industry vs. Captains of Finance
          • Successful Living >
            • Rules of Success
        • Firestone, Harvey S. >
          • Men and Rubber
          • Making an Organization
        • Flint, Charles R.
        • Ford, Henry >
          • Books by Henry Ford
          • The Last Billionaire
        • Gary, Elbert H.
        • Guggenheim, William
        • Hill, James J.
        • Hollerith, Herman
        • Johnson, George F.
        • Patterson, John H.
        • Penney, James C. >
          • Fifty Years With the Golden Rule
        • Procter, William C.
        • Rockefeller Sr., John D.
        • Rosenwald, Julius
        • Sloan Jr., Alfred P.
        • Swope, Gerard >
          • Swope of G.E.
          • The Swope Plan
          • Selected Addresses
        • Verity, George M. >
          • True Steel
          • Character & Success
        • Wanamaker, John >
          • A Business Biography
          • Retail Firsts
        • Watson Jr., Thomas J. >
          • A Business and Its Beliefs
          • Management Briefings
          • Father, Son & Company
        • Watson Sr., Thomas J. >
          • Human Relations
          • Men-Minutes-Money
          • The Lengthening Shadow
        • Young, Owen D. >
          • Selected Addresses
          • New Industrial Leader
      • Capitalists >
        • Baruch, Bernard M. >
          • My Own Story
          • The Public Years >
            • A Review
            • Second Thoughts
        • Schiff, Jacob H.
      • Journalists >
        • Baker, Ray Stannard >
          • Autobiography
          • The Color Line
          • Woodrow Wilson
        • Crowther, Samuel >
          • Articles >
            • Bantam Ball Bearing
          • Biographies
          • Industrialist Anthology
        • Gunther, John >
          • Eisenhower
        • Steffens, Lincoln
        • Sullivan, Mark >
          • Overview
          • Our Times
        • Tarbell, Ida M. >
          • Overview
          • Lincoln Centennial
          • Lincoln Publications
          • Corporate Publications
          • Fiction Publications
          • Other Publications
      • Publishers >
        • Forbes, B. C. >
          • Men Who Are Making America
          • Men Who Are Making the West
          • Automotive Giants of America
          • Little Bits about Big Men
          • America's 50 Foremost Business Leaders
          • Scrapbook of Thoughts on Business of Life
          • America's Twelve Master Salesmen
          • 101 Unusual Experiences
        • Shaw, A. W. >
          • Handling Men >
            • Why We Are Hiring Women
          • The Companion Series
      • Politicians >
        • Eisenhower, Dwight D.
        • Hoover, Herbert >
          • The Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson
          • The Problems of Lasting Peace
        • Lincoln, Abraham
        • Mesta, Perle
        • Roosevelt, Teddy
        • Wilson, Woodrow >
          • The New Freedom
          • The Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson
          • Life and Letters >
            • Volume IV: President
            • Volume V: Neutrality
            • Volume VI: Facing War
          • Woodrow Wilson's Last Words
      • Educators >
        • Booker T. Washington >
          • Up From Slavery
          • Character Building
    • Research Sites
    • Acknowledgements
  • 21st Century IBM
    • Corporate Performance >
      • Comparing KPIs
      • Brand Performance >
        • Forbes' Best Employer
      • Patent Performance >
        • 2021 Patent Performance
        • 2020 Patent Performance
        • 2019 Patent Performance
        • 2018 Patent Performance
      • Revenue Performance
    • Corporate Practices >
      • Acquisitions >
        • Acquisition: Red Hat >
          • A $35 Billion Gamble
          • IBM + Red Hat 2019 Results
        • Acquisitions: Goodwill
        • Acquisitions: Since 2001
      • Centralization >
        • A Lost Federation
        • The Need to Decentralize
      • Divestitures >
        • Kyndryl Analysis
        • Kyndryl Top Questions
        • Martin Schroeter
      • Employees >
        • Resource Actions
        • Age Discrimination >
          • Cutting Old Heads
        • Employee Engagement
        • Aren't Buying Into IBM
        • Massive Work Slowdown
        • Failure of Work at Home
      • Financial Engineering >
        • Workforce Rebalancing
        • Aggressive Bookkeeping
      • Shareholders >
        • Share Buybacks
        • Shareholder Risk
        • Employee Engagement
        • Warren Buffett's Mistake
        • Do Share Buybacks Work?
    • CEO Performance >
      • Arvind Krishna Overview >
        • Overall Performance >
          • Revenue & Profit
          • Revenue & Profit Growth
          • Revenue & Profit Productivity
          • IBM Market Value
          • Shareholder Returns & Risk
          • Employment Security
        • First Year Performance >
          • Revenue & Profit
          • Revenue & Profit Growth
          • Revenue & Profit Productivity
          • IBM Market Value
          • Shareholder Returns & Risk
          • Share Buybacks
        • The First 100 Days
      • Ginni Rometty Overview >
        • Shareholder Value
        • Shareholder Risk
        • Share Buybacks
        • Dividend Strategy
        • Acquisition Strategy
        • Revenue & Profit Productivity
        • Revenue & Profit Growth
        • Revenue & Profit
  • 20th Century IBM
    • Corporate Performance >
      • IBM's Greatest CEO >
        • Shareholder Returns
        • Revenue Growth
        • Revenue Per Employee
        • Profit Growth
        • Profit Per Employee
        • Market Value
        • Goodwill
        • Economic Contractions
        • Economic Expansions
        • Stock Market Headwinds
        • CEO Historic Footnotes >
          • IBM's Founding Team
          • Financial Engineering
          • The Greatest Gamble
    • Corporate Practices >
      • IBM Anniversaries
      • IBM Benefits
      • IBM Creativity >
        • IBM Cartoons
        • IBM Song Books
        • IBM UK Dictionary
        • IBM Computing Dictionary
      • IBM Wild Ducks >
        • The Wild Goose
        • Royal Dissenters
        • Corporate Constitution
        • Respect for the Individual
        • Service to the Customer
        • Pursuit of Excellence
    • Corporate Products >
      • 1890: U.S. Census
      • 1920: Dayton Scales
      • 1940: The Electromatic
    • Thomas J. Watson Sr. >
      • Articles by Watson >
        • On World Peace
        • On the Cost of War
        • On Public Education
        • On Thomas Jefferson
        • On Thoughtful Mistakes
        • On Stakeholder Relations
      • Articles about Watson >
        • The $1,000-A-Day Chief Executive Officer
        • Employees are Valued
        • Democracy's Man o' War
        • Human Relations in 1956
        • A CEO Who Earned His Pay
        • The Lengthening Shadow
      • Slice of Life Stories >
        • Dali, Salvador
        • Drucker, Peter F. >
          • Authority and Power
          • Short-Term Thinking
          • A Corporate Culture
          • Raising Business Issues
          • Focus on Principles
          • Character and Manners
          • Knowledge Workers
          • Recognizing Ability
          • Individual Respect
          • Employee Paternalism
        • Eastman, George
        • Penney, J. C. (James Cash) >
          • Watson Homestead
          • Golden Rule Businesses
        • Fighting Discrimination
      • Pre-World War II >
        • A Lost Dream of Peace
        • USO Camp Show Founder
      • World War II Effort >
        • Selling War Bonds
        • Production Awards
        • Controlling Profits
        • Machine Records Units
        • Wartime Contributions
        • Widows & Orphans Fund
        • Declaring Human Rights
        • Supporting Home Morale
        • Employee Military Service
        • War's End & Reconversion
      • Post-World War II >
        • Endicott Memorial
        • Poughkeepsie Memorial
        • Rehiring WWII Veterans
      • A Pajama Party
      • A 1943 Tax Problem
      • The Story of "THINK"
      • A Gift of Retirement
      • Learning from Crises
      • IBM Employee Housing >
        • Construction Timeline
      • Two Journalists "THINK"
      • A Buddy Davis Interview
      • Quotes of Watson
      • Quotes about Watson
      • Women in the Workplace
      • A Successful Rebranding
      • Tom Watson's Wild Ducks
  • Articles
    • Corporate Articles >
      • High-Performance Corporations
      • The Art of the Restart
      • Crises, Recoveries & Lessons Learned
      • Strategy Should Create Human Relationships
      • A Time-Tested Corporate Constitution
      • IBM, JC Penney and The Golden Rule
      • How IBM Created its 20th Century Brand
      • The Greatest Business Risk of the 20th Century
      • How to Grow a Business
      • The Importance of Sales Productivity
      • How Much Is a Great CEO Worth
      • Let Your Guard Down
    • Business Articles >
      • Business Witticism
      • The Golden Rule in Business
      • Who and What Built Early American Capitalism
      • Capitalism Needs Industrialist Minded CEOs
      • Producing Corporate True Steel
      • CEO Perspectives >
        • Rules of Success
        • Top Employee Qualities
        • Industrialist vs. Capitalist
      • An Open Letter to the World's CEOs
      • Henry Ford Takes Control
      • The Razor Blade Business Model
      • Two Successful 20th Century Businesswomen
      • Sears: A Dead Franchise Walking
      • A LinkedIn Incognito Mode
      • Value a College Education
    • Political Articles >
      • Political Witticisms
      • Memorial Day
      • Pursuing The "American Way"
      • America: Home of the Brave
      • Securing the Borders of the Americas
      • General Grant's Stand for Justice
      • America's Heartland Stands Strong
      • The New Freedom
      • Teddy Roosevelt on Socialism
    • Spiritual Articles >
      • Inauguration Day Prayer
      • Wilson's Last Words
      • Spiritual Songs
    • Fiction Articles >
      • A Father's Love
      • Introducing a Friend to God
      • Hyphenated Relationships
  • Contact
  • Blog

If my foresight were as clear as my hindsight, I should be better off by a damned sight.

J. L. Mott, President of the Iron and Steel Association, 1873

IBM First-Year (2019) Red Hat Revenue

Published January 31, 2020
Updated April 2, 2022
A color bar chart dedicated to the IBM - Red Hat acquisition and putting the first-year IBM and Red Hat revenue in perspective.
This chart is purposely scaled so that the reader may see the change in Red Hat's revenue over time and, specifically, 2018-2019​—the first year of the acquisition. Without this scale the Red Hat revenue would be such a miniscule part of IBM's total revenue that it would not be visible.
An Evaluation of IBM's Red Hat Acquisition and its 2019 Financial Results
  • The Wall Street Perspective in Print
  • The Revenue Facts: Charting Virginia M. Rometty's Performance
  • How Has IBM Historically Produced Stable, Growing Revenue?
  • What Is the Revenue Big Picture?
  • IBM Isn't Firing on all Cylinders
  • Three Decades Ago, IBM Fell in a Hurry
  • Author's Opinion: Falling Revenue is a Symptom of Bigger Issues

 The Wall Street Perspective in Print
Depending on what publication you read, it have may sounded like IBM turned a corner in its January 21, 2020 earnings announcement:
  • Seeking Alpha wrote:
    • “IBM: Turnaround is Here.”
  • Business Insider wrote:
    • “IBM got a boost from Red Hat and its results show buying it was smart.”
  • Motley Fool wrote:
    • “IBM Looks Good in that Red Hat.”
  • WRAL TechWire went all out:
    • “IBM Reports Spike in Revenue.”
  • The Wall Street Journal joined the parade … cautiously:
    • “IBM Earnings Hint at Signs of a Turnaround.”
  • Forbes added a literal “but” to its title, while the Financial Times suggested one:
    • “IBM’s Quarterly Sales Finally Rose—But Not by Much.”
    • “IBM is growing its sales again. Just”
Some analysts and reporters are Wall Street driven. Their motivation is to call a bottom on a stock price, not discern a corporate turnaround. There is nothing wrong with this, as long as the reader understands their motivation, and that they are not business analysts who are knowledgeable of a particular corporation’s long-term strengths and weaknesses.
​
For the most part, Wall Street analysts found excitement in IBM’s latest quarter: the company raised revenue in the fourth quarter of 2019 over 2018 by .078125%. Yes, the decimal point is in the right place: $21,777 billion in the fourth quarter of 2019 vs. $21,760 billion in the fourth quarter of 2018. (To remove the vagueness of billions, this is the equivalent of a thousand-dollar-a-quarter company doing an additional .78 cents, or a million-dollar-a-quarter company doing an additional $780.)
​
It would take more than this to excite a true business analyst, eh?
The Revenue Facts: Charting Virginia M. Rometty’s Performance
IBM’s problems started in 1995, and they have been on-going for more than two decades. Its sales and profit productivity flattened in 1995 and started their decline in 1999. This is a first in IBM’s 100+ year history and a sign of the cultural mess the company has become.

​Virginia M. Rometty inherited this fiasco from Gerstner and Palmisano, but her actions, similar to theirs, exacerbated the problem. It will take more than a .078125% improvement in quarterly revenue—especially after paying $34 billion for Red Hat—to claim the problems are fixed. ​
Even with Red Hat, last year’s revenue fell by 3.1%, and since Ginni took charge in 2012, revenue is down by 27.8%. (Remember that fictional million-dollar-a-quarter company that generated an additional $780 last quarterly? Well, 2018’s full-year sales of $4 million would have dropped by $124,000, and since the end of 2012, yearly sales would have dropped from $5,540,000. This makes it hard to get excited about $780, doesn’t it?)

With this perspective, here is Virginia M. Rometty's revenue record.
A three-color bar chart with IBM's, Red Hat's and IBM + Red Hat's revenue from 2011 through 2019.
Revenue has declined from $107 billion to $77 billion. This is a catastrophic revenue drop of almost 28%—despite sixty-three acquisitions in her first eighty-four months (Red Hat was number 64).

​Obviously, sales didn't profit from these small acquisitions.
 How Has IBM Historically Produced Stable, Growing Revenue?
Reading the chief financial officer’s comments and the questions of the analysts, I thought how easy it is to get lost in all of IBM’s moving parts, and the chief financial officer was all about reviewing the revenue engine’s piece parts: Systems (mainframe, power and storage), Cloud & Cognitive, Global Business Services, and Global Technology Services. The whole discussion failed to answer a simple question: “Overall, how is the corporation doing?”
IBM has always been a multitude of linked, dependent, development organizations. They must work together like the pistons in the engine of a car in order to provide stable, growing revenue and profitability. Individual development organizations, along with their supportive sales organizations, like a piston, take “breathers.” On a “down stroke” they pull in a new charge of gas mixed with air and then compress the mixture awaiting a timely ignition.
​
​Each organization takes in its customers’ requirements (gas), combines it with competitive development ingenuity (air) and then releases a product update for marketing and sales to ignite (ignition) … all of this looks pretty ugly in operation across multiple organizations, but when coordinated and working in cooperation with each other, they accomplish an amazing task: they transfer continuous, on-going power (revenue) to a transmission which can then be geared to drive slow or fast given the economic terrain to maintain a sustained movement in a strategic direction.
An image of a car engine with the chief executive officer as the timing change driving sales revenue.
The chief executive officer is the "timing chain" that ensures a balanced performance between independent, cooperative organizations: coordinated decentralization.
IBM over its 100+ year history has been, figuratively speaking, three-, four-, six- and eight-cylinder engines. Today, it is in a worse position than being a one-cylinder engine. It is a multi-cylinder engine which is misfiring. Not only are the organizations not helping each other, but they impede the corporations overall growth because finance—although it has abandoned the long-term, earnings per share roadmaps—is now focused on short-term, earnings-per-share targets. This constantly throttles back the amount of investment dollars available to all organizations. Starved for investment dollars, they misfire at the most inopportune times. All of this works against the efficiency of the revenue engine.

IBM misfires because its financial autocracy is starving the entire organization of investment funds, and its right arm—the human resources organization—is either demotivating and driving its best people out of the organization or failing to retain them. In fact, a Master Inventor left the corporation on the day of the analysts' call [here].

​This makes the corporation inefficient, ineffective and unpredictable in revenue production; and there is no easy fix that will be found in one quarter’s microscopic revenue growth.

So, understanding this, how is the IBM revenue engine performing?
 What Is the Revenue Big Picture?
After reading the transcript of the analysts’ call, I wondered, “What is the big picture here?” It seemed logical to start with a baseline measurement: capture how IBM and Red Hat performed when they were still separate organizations in 2018. This baseline number could be used to measure the merits of this acquisition in future years. It seems logical that if IBM’s total revenue in future years (which will now include all Red Hat revenue) is significantly less than this baseline, it would be hard—with a straight face—to call the merger a success.

This simple measurement would cut through all the movement of the various corporate piece parts within the company and answer one basic question: How are IBM and Red Hat doing as a combined organization? ​Doesn’t it seem logical and appropriate that a $34 billion acquisition by a $80 billion dollar company should answer such a simple question clearly?
This chart shows IBM’s and Red Hat’s combined revenue in 2018 and 2019.
​
In red, is Red Hat’s revenue in 2018 and the first half of 2019—when it was independent of IBM. In green, is Red Hat’s revenue in the second half of 2019—as reported by IBM. In blue, is IBM’s core revenue—Big Blue revenue less Red Hat revenue.

The critical observation is that IBM + Red Hat’s total combined 2019 revenue (blue + green + red) fell by almost $4 billion from 2018.​
A three-color bar chart that shows 2018 and 2019 revenue for IBM and Red Hat.
​After spending $35.1 billion for a comparatively tiny corporation that was supposed to save IBM, this is a financial hand grenade. Being off by even a billion will make little difference if the trend continues into 2020. [See Footnote]

The clue to this fall, was presumably contained in one sentence, but since IBM’s chief financial officer seems to rarely offer specific details, we will make some detailed assumptions.
 IBM Isn't Firing on all Cylinders
Optimistically, the chief financial officer said that IBM’s mainframe sales were up “a strong 63%” and that the corporation experienced the “highest MIPs in history this quarter, driven by growth in new workloads.”

​In the past, a 63% increase in quarterly mainframe sales and a new quarterly record in additional MIPs would have literally blown IBM’s revenue and profit numbers out of the water … if the revenue engine were firing on all cylinders.
​Comparing the end of year quarterly results for 2018 and 2019 doesn’t reveal any drastic increase in revenue as would be expected. [An excellent overview of Systems Group performance and Power Systems in particular is Timothy Morgan's "Power9 Enters the Long Tail."]

The chief financial officer noted that, “Growth in IBM z and Storage was mitigated by a decline in Power.” From the charts above, “mitigated” seems to be a very diplomatic choice of words. IBM needs to put it together across the entire corporation. It must start firing on all cylinders. A large diverse corporation such as IBM requires that every organization be staffed with engaged, passionate and enthusiastic product, brand and marketing managers, salesmen, technical-sales, service and support, developers and architects who are coordinated, supported and rewarded by the best of executive leadership at all levels of the organization.

This is the responsibility of the chief executive officer of the corporation, and she has failed.
​
And economic failure, as IBM has proven in the past, can come quickly.
 Three Decades Ago, IBM Fell in a Hurry
For those who believe that IBM’s profitability is too great to result in the corporation being pushed to the edge of bankruptcy any time soon, consider the chart to the right.

​At the beginning of another decade (1990), IBM shipped the System/390 which was arguably a more significant upgrade to a much larger and more loyal mainframe install base than enjoyed by today’s IBM z15. The following years should have been years of plenty, but the corporation swung in one year from a $6 billion profit (the third highest net income in the history of the company to that point) to a $3 billion loss in 1991, a $5 billion loss in 1992, and then an $8 billion loss in 1993.​
A bar chart showing IBM's Net Income plunge from 1989-1990 to 1991-1992 under John F. Akers.
Even with the shipment of the System/390 and the RS/6000 in 1990 IBM's net earnings plunged in 1991
John Akers for all his mistakes made the most crucial error of his career when he accused his fellow IBMers in 1991 of “standing around water coolers.” By 1992, most everyone had discerned that the corner office was the problem, not its people. This pales in comparison to what Virginia M. Rometty has done to her fellow IBMers through 401(k) modifications, resource actions, and personal/performance improvement plan (PIP) modifications [the latter of which is proving highly effective in trimming the sales organization through assignment of unattainable sales quotas] .

​IBM’s most valuable resource, its human assets, are no longer tied to long-term pension plans. There are better benefits, higher pay, and actual job security elsewhere in the industry, and the loyalty of the individual to the corporation is not on par with what it was during the crisis of 1992-93.
 Author's Opinion: Falling Revenue is a Symptom of Bigger Issues
Picture of crystal ball with two hands and an IBM stock price chart.
After the analysts' call, IBM stock climbed from ​139.09 to 144.89, only to close at 138.62 on Jan 27—​four trading days later.
No one can predict the future—either next quarter or next year—but the revenue tea leaves the Wall Street analysts are reading in the bottom of their teacups do not justify an optimistic outlook.

A speculator might take the odds that IBM will have another quarter of growth [which it failed to do in the first quarter of 2020]. ​A speculator might even take the odds that Wall Street will once again set its expectations so low that IBM can send its stock higher—for a few days—with another .078125% "spike" in quarterly revenue. After all, this is Wall Street.

Speculators can print money whether the stock goes up or down.​ Employees have a much different perspective, and so should their chief executive.
We will see if Arvind Krishna​ has a new perspective on what is wrong with IBM [He doesn't]. He will have to fix two decades of declining sales productivity and that will not be easy because IBM’s problem is a human relations problem.

Until IBM has multiple quarters or even multiple years of significant back-to-back revenue growth—it isn’t back. Especially when I have seen one of the largest migrations of individuals from IBM in a long time. Very good people are not only still being cut loose by the corporation to fund the on-going earnings-per-share beast, but now, very good people are leaving of their own accord. It appears that many individuals planned their exits around IBM’s archaic 401(k) vesting rules and are now moving on to other jobs (to get IBM's matching dollars each year you can't leave IBM for any reason other than retirement before December 15 of each year).

Unfortunately, there are more and bigger problems than revenue growth—the focus of this article. There are a slew of other problems lurking on the horizon: coming goodwill impairments, an increasingly negative, shareholder-equity-less-goodwill, and the on-going lack of employee engagement, passion and enthusiasm. 

Cheers
​
Pete

[Footnote] In order to produce these charts, the author avoided letting perfection prevent the presentation of good enough. Red Hat’s fiscal year ended in February of each year. This presented difficulties aligning year-to-year revenue from the two corporation’s quarterly reports. The author believes that the way the data is presented in this chart, even though it omits Red Hat revenue for June 2019, actually shows a best-case scenario for IBM since December 2018 is included in the 2019 revenue numbers. Perfection would be to have monthly revenue numbers for Red Hat, but these numbers are not available unless IBM decides to provide them.
© 2022 Peter E. Greulich. All Rights Reserved
​
Information posted on this site recognizes the legal right of copyrighted material. The following material is considered in the public domain effective January 1, 2022: (1) works published in the United States prior to 1927, (2) works published in the United States after 1926 but before 1964 with a proper © copyright notice that were not renewed in their 28th year, and (3) works published in the United States before 1978 that have no © copyright notice, and (4) all unpublished works created over 120 years ago. Other documents used here that do not fit these criteria are used in good faith and a belief that such usage would withstand a test of fair use. Any concerns with the public domain or fair usage of material on this site will be removed until a discussion can resolve the matter with its permanent removal or republication. Just use the "Contact" menu item above or the "Contact Us" hyperlink provided here: [Contact Us]
  • Home
  • About
  • Books / Bibliography
    • THINK Again! >
      • Preface
      • Foreword
      • Introduction
      • Business Talk Interview
      • Book Trailers and Videos
    • A View from Beneath >
      • Preface
      • Resource Actions >
        • Two R.A. Days Hit Home
        • R.A. Day Kills Productivity
      • Business Talk Interview
      • Book Trailers and Videos
    • The World's Greatest Salesman >
      • Preface
      • Introduction
      • Workplace Safety
      • Images and Quotes
      • Book Trailers / Videos
    • Essays on Leadership >
      • Democracy in Business
      • We Are All Assistants >
        • Frank Venner: We Are All Assistants
      • We Forgive Thoughtful Mistakes
    • Bibliography Overview >
      • IBM >
        • IBM Books >
          • IBM Classics
          • IBM Executives' Books
          • IBM Employees' Books
          • IBM Outsiders' Books
        • IBM Publications >
          • THINK Magazine
          • Business Machines
          • IBM Heart and Soul >
            • Endicott Memorial Day
            • Poughkeepsie Memorial Day
          • IBM Art Books
        • IBM Situational
      • Industrialists >
        • Anthologies >
          • The Book of Business
          • New Ideals in Business
          • Master Workers' Library
          • The Age of Big Business
          • Famous Leaders Series Home Page >
            • Leaders of Character
            • Leaders of Industry: 1st Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 2nd Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 3rd Series
            • Leaders of Industry: 6th Series
          • Forbes' Anthologies
        • Armour, J. Ogden >
          • The Packers
          • The Packers: Second Look
        • Baldwin, William H.
        • Beatty, Edward
        • Bell, Alexander Graham
        • Carnegie, Andrew >
          • Carnegie Quotes
          • Carnegie Autobiography
          • Carnegie Biography by B. J. Hendrick
          • Round the World
          • The Empire of Business
          • An American Four-in-Hand
        • Eastman, George
        • Edison, Thomas A. >
          • Edison: His Life and Inventions
          • Edison: My Friend
        • Farquhar, A. B.
        • Filene, Edward A. >
          • The Way Out >
            • Captains of Industry vs. Captains of Finance
          • Successful Living >
            • Rules of Success
        • Firestone, Harvey S. >
          • Men and Rubber
          • Making an Organization
        • Flint, Charles R.
        • Ford, Henry >
          • Books by Henry Ford
          • The Last Billionaire
        • Gary, Elbert H.
        • Guggenheim, William
        • Hill, James J.
        • Hollerith, Herman
        • Johnson, George F.
        • Patterson, John H.
        • Penney, James C. >
          • Fifty Years With the Golden Rule
        • Procter, William C.
        • Rockefeller Sr., John D.
        • Rosenwald, Julius
        • Sloan Jr., Alfred P.
        • Swope, Gerard >
          • Swope of G.E.
          • The Swope Plan
          • Selected Addresses
        • Verity, George M. >
          • True Steel
          • Character & Success
        • Wanamaker, John >
          • A Business Biography
          • Retail Firsts
        • Watson Jr., Thomas J. >
          • A Business and Its Beliefs
          • Management Briefings
          • Father, Son & Company
        • Watson Sr., Thomas J. >
          • Human Relations
          • Men-Minutes-Money
          • The Lengthening Shadow
        • Young, Owen D. >
          • Selected Addresses
          • New Industrial Leader
      • Capitalists >
        • Baruch, Bernard M. >
          • My Own Story
          • The Public Years >
            • A Review
            • Second Thoughts
        • Schiff, Jacob H.
      • Journalists >
        • Baker, Ray Stannard >
          • Autobiography
          • The Color Line
          • Woodrow Wilson
        • Crowther, Samuel >
          • Articles >
            • Bantam Ball Bearing
          • Biographies
          • Industrialist Anthology
        • Gunther, John >
          • Eisenhower
        • Steffens, Lincoln
        • Sullivan, Mark >
          • Overview
          • Our Times
        • Tarbell, Ida M. >
          • Overview
          • Lincoln Centennial
          • Lincoln Publications
          • Corporate Publications
          • Fiction Publications
          • Other Publications
      • Publishers >
        • Forbes, B. C. >
          • Men Who Are Making America
          • Men Who Are Making the West
          • Automotive Giants of America
          • Little Bits about Big Men
          • America's 50 Foremost Business Leaders
          • Scrapbook of Thoughts on Business of Life
          • America's Twelve Master Salesmen
          • 101 Unusual Experiences
        • Shaw, A. W. >
          • Handling Men >
            • Why We Are Hiring Women
          • The Companion Series
      • Politicians >
        • Eisenhower, Dwight D.
        • Hoover, Herbert >
          • The Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson
          • The Problems of Lasting Peace
        • Lincoln, Abraham
        • Mesta, Perle
        • Roosevelt, Teddy
        • Wilson, Woodrow >
          • The New Freedom
          • The Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson
          • Life and Letters >
            • Volume IV: President
            • Volume V: Neutrality
            • Volume VI: Facing War
          • Woodrow Wilson's Last Words
      • Educators >
        • Booker T. Washington >
          • Up From Slavery
          • Character Building
    • Research Sites
    • Acknowledgements
  • 21st Century IBM
    • Corporate Performance >
      • Comparing KPIs
      • Brand Performance >
        • Forbes' Best Employer
      • Patent Performance >
        • 2021 Patent Performance
        • 2020 Patent Performance
        • 2019 Patent Performance
        • 2018 Patent Performance
      • Revenue Performance
    • Corporate Practices >
      • Acquisitions >
        • Acquisition: Red Hat >
          • A $35 Billion Gamble
          • IBM + Red Hat 2019 Results
        • Acquisitions: Goodwill
        • Acquisitions: Since 2001
      • Centralization >
        • A Lost Federation
        • The Need to Decentralize
      • Divestitures >
        • Kyndryl Analysis
        • Kyndryl Top Questions
        • Martin Schroeter
      • Employees >
        • Resource Actions
        • Age Discrimination >
          • Cutting Old Heads
        • Employee Engagement
        • Aren't Buying Into IBM
        • Massive Work Slowdown
        • Failure of Work at Home
      • Financial Engineering >
        • Workforce Rebalancing
        • Aggressive Bookkeeping
      • Shareholders >
        • Share Buybacks
        • Shareholder Risk
        • Employee Engagement
        • Warren Buffett's Mistake
        • Do Share Buybacks Work?
    • CEO Performance >
      • Arvind Krishna Overview >
        • Overall Performance >
          • Revenue & Profit
          • Revenue & Profit Growth
          • Revenue & Profit Productivity
          • IBM Market Value
          • Shareholder Returns & Risk
          • Employment Security
        • First Year Performance >
          • Revenue & Profit
          • Revenue & Profit Growth
          • Revenue & Profit Productivity
          • IBM Market Value
          • Shareholder Returns & Risk
          • Share Buybacks
        • The First 100 Days
      • Ginni Rometty Overview >
        • Shareholder Value
        • Shareholder Risk
        • Share Buybacks
        • Dividend Strategy
        • Acquisition Strategy
        • Revenue & Profit Productivity
        • Revenue & Profit Growth
        • Revenue & Profit
  • 20th Century IBM
    • Corporate Performance >
      • IBM's Greatest CEO >
        • Shareholder Returns
        • Revenue Growth
        • Revenue Per Employee
        • Profit Growth
        • Profit Per Employee
        • Market Value
        • Goodwill
        • Economic Contractions
        • Economic Expansions
        • Stock Market Headwinds
        • CEO Historic Footnotes >
          • IBM's Founding Team
          • Financial Engineering
          • The Greatest Gamble
    • Corporate Practices >
      • IBM Anniversaries
      • IBM Benefits
      • IBM Creativity >
        • IBM Cartoons
        • IBM Song Books
        • IBM UK Dictionary
        • IBM Computing Dictionary
      • IBM Wild Ducks >
        • The Wild Goose
        • Royal Dissenters
        • Corporate Constitution
        • Respect for the Individual
        • Service to the Customer
        • Pursuit of Excellence
    • Corporate Products >
      • 1890: U.S. Census
      • 1920: Dayton Scales
      • 1940: The Electromatic
    • Thomas J. Watson Sr. >
      • Articles by Watson >
        • On World Peace
        • On the Cost of War
        • On Public Education
        • On Thomas Jefferson
        • On Thoughtful Mistakes
        • On Stakeholder Relations
      • Articles about Watson >
        • The $1,000-A-Day Chief Executive Officer
        • Employees are Valued
        • Democracy's Man o' War
        • Human Relations in 1956
        • A CEO Who Earned His Pay
        • The Lengthening Shadow
      • Slice of Life Stories >
        • Dali, Salvador
        • Drucker, Peter F. >
          • Authority and Power
          • Short-Term Thinking
          • A Corporate Culture
          • Raising Business Issues
          • Focus on Principles
          • Character and Manners
          • Knowledge Workers
          • Recognizing Ability
          • Individual Respect
          • Employee Paternalism
        • Eastman, George
        • Penney, J. C. (James Cash) >
          • Watson Homestead
          • Golden Rule Businesses
        • Fighting Discrimination
      • Pre-World War II >
        • A Lost Dream of Peace
        • USO Camp Show Founder
      • World War II Effort >
        • Selling War Bonds
        • Production Awards
        • Controlling Profits
        • Machine Records Units
        • Wartime Contributions
        • Widows & Orphans Fund
        • Declaring Human Rights
        • Supporting Home Morale
        • Employee Military Service
        • War's End & Reconversion
      • Post-World War II >
        • Endicott Memorial
        • Poughkeepsie Memorial
        • Rehiring WWII Veterans
      • A Pajama Party
      • A 1943 Tax Problem
      • The Story of "THINK"
      • A Gift of Retirement
      • Learning from Crises
      • IBM Employee Housing >
        • Construction Timeline
      • Two Journalists "THINK"
      • A Buddy Davis Interview
      • Quotes of Watson
      • Quotes about Watson
      • Women in the Workplace
      • A Successful Rebranding
      • Tom Watson's Wild Ducks
  • Articles
    • Corporate Articles >
      • High-Performance Corporations
      • The Art of the Restart
      • Crises, Recoveries & Lessons Learned
      • Strategy Should Create Human Relationships
      • A Time-Tested Corporate Constitution
      • IBM, JC Penney and The Golden Rule
      • How IBM Created its 20th Century Brand
      • The Greatest Business Risk of the 20th Century
      • How to Grow a Business
      • The Importance of Sales Productivity
      • How Much Is a Great CEO Worth
      • Let Your Guard Down
    • Business Articles >
      • Business Witticism
      • The Golden Rule in Business
      • Who and What Built Early American Capitalism
      • Capitalism Needs Industrialist Minded CEOs
      • Producing Corporate True Steel
      • CEO Perspectives >
        • Rules of Success
        • Top Employee Qualities
        • Industrialist vs. Capitalist
      • An Open Letter to the World's CEOs
      • Henry Ford Takes Control
      • The Razor Blade Business Model
      • Two Successful 20th Century Businesswomen
      • Sears: A Dead Franchise Walking
      • A LinkedIn Incognito Mode
      • Value a College Education
    • Political Articles >
      • Political Witticisms
      • Memorial Day
      • Pursuing The "American Way"
      • America: Home of the Brave
      • Securing the Borders of the Americas
      • General Grant's Stand for Justice
      • America's Heartland Stands Strong
      • The New Freedom
      • Teddy Roosevelt on Socialism
    • Spiritual Articles >
      • Inauguration Day Prayer
      • Wilson's Last Words
      • Spiritual Songs
    • Fiction Articles >
      • A Father's Love
      • Introducing a Friend to God
      • Hyphenated Relationships
  • Contact
  • Blog